Resolving Shareholder and Partner Disputes

Branded graphic reading Shareholder, Partner or LLC Member: find your role, documents and next step
Shareholder and partner disputes at the Law Offices of Aaron Resnick, Miami.

Shareholder and Partner Disputes: Navigating Challenges in Business Relationships

Introduction

Shareholder and partner disputes can be among the most challenging issues faced by any business, potentially threatening its stability and future. Such conflicts often arise from disagreements over business operations, profit distributions, or the strategic direction of the company. Aaron Resnick, a Miami business attorney, represents shareholders and partners in negotiations and court proceedings to protect their ownership interests and, where possible, preserve the business.

A shareholder dispute happens inside a corporation, a partner dispute inside a partnership and a member dispute inside an LLC. Miami business attorney Aaron Resnick starts by identifying which one you are in from the formation and ownership records, because each has its own Florida statute and its own governing documents.

What Is a Shareholder or Partner Dispute?

A shareholder or partner dispute is a conflict among the owners of a business. Shareholder disputes arise in a corporation. Partner disputes arise in a partnership, which forms when two or more people or entities carry on a business for profit as co owners, whether or not they intend to form a partnership (chapter 620 of the Florida Statutes).

Shareholder disputes occur in corporations, typically among the company's equity holders. Partner disputes occur in partnerships, where two or more people or entities carry on a business for profit as co owners. Although each type of dispute has its unique context, both share common ground in the conflicts that arise from business relationships and operations.

Common Causes of Disputes:

  • Differences in Vision and Strategy: Divergent ideas about the company's direction can lead to significant conflicts among business owners.

  • Financial Concerns: Disagreements over profit sharing, reinvestment in the business, and financial management are common.

  • Breach of Fiduciary Duty: Accusations that a partner or director has acted against the company's best interests can lead to serious legal disputes.

  • Operational Management: Disputes often arise from day-to-day management decisions, which may favor the interest of one party over another.

When Do You Need a Shareholder or Partner Dispute Lawyer?

You need a shareholder or partner dispute lawyer when a vote, a transfer of ownership, a distribution or a management decision that affects your stake was made without you, or when you are cut off from the records that would show what happened.

Name the one action you object to, then find who approved it, when, and under which document. The table below shows who decides by default in each kind of business.

How Do You Identify Your Role in the Business?

Your role comes from the formation and ownership records, not from a title on a business card. A shareholder owns shares in a corporation. A partner is one of two or more people or entities carrying on a business for profit as co owners, whether or not they intended to form a partnership (chapter 620 of the Florida Statutes).

An LLC member is someone admitted as a member under Florida law and the company's governing documents. A person can be a member without holding a transferable interest, and buying a member's transferable interest does not by itself make the buyer a member or give the buyer a role in management (chapter 605; chapter 605).

Check the company's filed articles, its share or membership records and its agreements. A partnership agreement may be written, oral or implied (chapter 620), and so may an LLC operating agreement (chapter 605).

An LLC is member managed unless its articles or operating agreement expressly provide for managers or use words of similar import; the words "managing member" do not by themselves make it manager managed (chapter 605).

Which Documents Control a Shareholder, Partner or Member Dispute?

The documents that control depend on the entity: the articles, bylaws and any qualifying shareholder agreement for a corporation; the partnership agreement for a partnership; the articles of organization and operating agreement for an LLC.

Shareholder, partner or LLC member: the documents, default decision makers, records rights and duties in a Florida business
QuestionCorporation: shareholderGeneral partnership: partnerLLC: member
Documents that controlArticles of incorporation, bylaws and any shareholder agreement that meets the statute: set out or referenced in the articles or bylaws and approved by all shareholders at the time, or written, signed by all shareholders at the time and made known to the corporation (chapter 607)The partnership agreement, written, oral or implied, with amendments (chapter 620)Articles of organization and the operating agreement, which may be oral, implied, in a record or a combination (chapter 605)
Who runs the business by defaultThe business is managed by or under the direction, and subject to the oversight, of the board of directors, subject to the articles or a qualifying shareholder agreement (chapter 607)By default, every partner has equal management rights; a majority of the partners can decide an ordinary course difference; acts outside the ordinary course and amendments to the agreement need all partners (chapter 620)The members in a member managed LLC; the manager or managers in a manager managed LLC, except as the statute provides (chapter 605)
RecordsCore records on at least 5 business days' written notice before the inspection date. Excerpts of board minutes, financial statements and accounting records take the same notice plus a demand made in good faith and for a proper purpose that describes the purpose and the records with reasonable particularity, where the records are directly connected to that purpose (chapter 607)Access to the books and records to inspect and copy during ordinary business hours; needed information without demand, and other information on demand unless the demand or the information sought is unreasonable or otherwise improper (chapter 620)Member managed: on reasonable notice, the required records and other material records, during regular business hours at a reasonable location the company specifies. Manager managed: the required records during regular business hours at a reasonable location the company specifies, and, as is just and reasonable, other information only on a demand in a record received by the company that describes the information and the purpose with reasonable particularity, where the purpose is reasonably related to the member's interest and the information is directly connected to that purpose (chapter 605)
Who owes dutiesDirectors must act in good faith and in a manner they reasonably believe is in the corporation's best interests (chapter 607)Each partner owes loyalty and care to the partnership and the other partners (chapter 620)Managers of a manager managed LLC and members of a member managed LLC owe loyalty and care (chapter 605)
Shareholder, partner and LLC member compared: documents, decision makers, records rights and duties.

Legal Framework and Rights

The legal framework governing shareholder and partner disputes includes a mix of statutory law and the specific agreements entered into by the parties, such as shareholders' agreements or partnership agreements. Understanding these documents and the legal rights they confer to each party is crucial in managing disputes.

Key Legal Considerations:

  • Fiduciary Duties: In a Florida general partnership, partners owe loyalty and care to the partnership and to each other (chapter 620). Corporate directors must act in good faith and in the corporation's best interests as they reasonably understand them (chapter 607). In an LLC, managers of a manager managed company and members of a member managed company owe loyalty and care to the company and its members (chapter 605).

  • Contractual Obligations: Parties must adhere to the terms set out in any partnership or shareholders' agreement.

  • Minority Rights: Minority shareholders or partners have certain protections under the law to guard against being unfairly prejudiced by majority decisions.

How Are Shareholder and Partner Disputes Resolved?

Shareholder and partner disputes are resolved by negotiation, mediation or litigation, or by arbitration where the parties have a valid arbitration agreement. A buyout may be negotiated, or ordered where a legal basis applies.

Effective resolution of shareholder and partner disputes requires a strategic approach that balances legal outcomes with the need to maintain ongoing business relationships.

Resolution Strategies Include:

  1. Negotiation and Mediation: Where possible, disputes should be resolved through negotiation or mediation. These alternative dispute resolution methods can preserve business relationships and are often less costly and time-consuming than litigation.

  2. Arbitration: For disputes that are complex or where parties desire a binding resolution outside of court, arbitration can be an effective method.

  3. Litigation: As a last resort, litigation can resolve disputes definitively. While litigation is often more public and can be damaging to business relationships, it sometimes is necessary to protect a party's rights and interests.

Best Practices in Dispute Prevention

To minimize the occurrence of disputes, or to mitigate their impact should they arise, consider the following best practices:

  • Clear Agreements: Draft clear and comprehensive shareholders' or partnership agreements that include dispute resolution mechanisms.

  • Regular Communication: Hold regular meetings to discuss business operations, financial status, and strategies. Transparent communication can prevent misunderstandings and conflicts.

  • Independent Advisors: Utilize independent advisors or mediators for neutral advice or to facilitate difficult discussions.

  • Exit Strategies: Define clear exit strategies in your initial agreements to manage departures without dispute.

General Example: Resolving a Shareholder Dispute

General example, not a client matter.

Consider a scenario where a minority shareholder believes they are being excluded from critical decision making, affecting their investment and the overall health of the company. The owners could use mediation to agree on clearer rules for votes and information access.

An amended shareholders' agreement could then set clearer guidelines on decision making and minority shareholder rights, resolving the dispute amicably.

Which Page Covers Your Situation?

Pick the page that matches your role and the action in dispute.

All of these sit under partnership and shareholder disputes. Bring the ownership records, the agreement and a short description of the decision you dispute to the first review.

Related questions: What Should a Florida Shareholder Agreement Include? · Can My Partner Withhold Company Distributions? · What Do I Bring to a Partner Dispute Review?

Who Handles Shareholder and Partner Disputes in Miami?

Miami business attorney Aaron Resnick represents shareholders and partners in negotiations and court proceedings at the Law Offices of Aaron Resnick, in Miami Dade, Broward and Palm Beach counties.

He first confirms whether you are a shareholder, partner or member and reads the documents that control that role, then negotiates, mediates or litigates to protect your ownership interest and, where possible, the business.

Speak to Aaron about your role in the business, the agreement and the action you object to.

At the Law Offices of Aaron Resnick, we understand the complexity of shareholder and partner disputes and the impact they can have on your business. Our approach is tailored to meet the specific needs of each client, ensuring:

  • Expertise: Deep understanding of corporate law and partnership disputes.

  • Experience: Years of successfully resolving business disputes, both in and out of court.

  • Personalized Service: We prioritize your business objectives and work diligently to achieve the best possible outcome while minimizing disruption to your business operations.

Shareholder and partner disputes require careful handling to protect both the individuals involved and the business entity. Whether through negotiation, mediation, or courtroom litigation, the Law Offices of Aaron Resnick are equipped to manage and resolve these disputes effectively. If you are experiencing a business dispute, contact us to discuss how we can support you

We Don't Make Promises. We Have Results to Prove It.

Aaron Resnick has handled business disputes in Miami since 1998 and is a fourth generation Miami resident. He works hands-on on every case; the client gets Aaron on every major litigation issue, not a junior partner. The Law Offices of Aaron Resnick represents business owners, partners, members and shareholders in Miami Dade, Broward and Palm Beach counties in partnership, LLC and shareholder disputes, buyouts and dissolutions. Call 305-672-7495 or request a consultation.

This is general information, not legal advice. Viewing this page or contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship. Deadlines can be short. If your matter is time sensitive, call the office at 305-672-7495.

This page provides general information and is not legal advice. Prior results do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome.

Tell Aaron What Happened

Contact Our Firm

Areas We Serve in Florida

Miami Gardens | Aventura | Golden Beach | Sunny Isles Beach | North Miami Beach | North Miami | Bal Harbour | Bay Harbor Islands | Indian Creek | Surfside | Biscayne Park | Miami Shores | El Portal | North Bay Village | Opa-locka | Miami Lakes | Hialeah | Hialeah Gardens | Medley | Doral | Miami Springs | Virginia Gardens | Sweetwater | Miami | Miami Beach | Key Biscayne | West Miami | Coral Gables | South Miami | Pinecrest | Palmetto Bay | Cutler Bay | Homestead | Florida City

Aaron Resnick Day, Miami Beach

Celebrating Aaron Resnick Day City of Miami Beach - Vibrant Art Deco Style Celebration Graphic with Palm Trees Fireworks and Neon Lights