Real Estate Broker Commission Disputes

Miami attorney for brokers, agents, and brokerages owed a commission, and for the sellers and developers who face those claims.

You did the work. You signed the listing, marketed the property, brought buyers through the door. Then the listing expired, and days or weeks later the property sold to a buyer you never heard of, through a broker who barely touched the deal. Or the seller simply refused to pay. In South Florida’s high-end market, where a single commission can reach seven figures, these disputes are common.

The Law Offices of Aaron Resnick represents real estate brokers, agents, teams, and brokerages, from independent agents to national firms, in commission disputes throughout Florida. We bring claims against sellers, developers, buyers, and other brokerages, and we also defend sellers and developers, which helps us anticipate the arguments on both sides.

Commission Disputes We Handle

  • The “expire and close” sale. A buyer is identified during the listing but kept quiet until it expires, and the deal closes shortly afterward.
  • Protection period claims. The property sells within the protection period to a prospect who saw it or was in contact during the listing.
  • Contracts signed during the listing. A purchase contract signed during the term, which extends the broker’s rights through closing.
  • Seller or developer direct deals. A seller, developer, or their representative deals directly with a buyer and cuts out the listing broker.
  • Token-fee “successor brokers.” A brokerage paid a nominal fee to put its name on a pre-arranged sale so the seller can claim the property was relisted.
  • Office exclusive and off-MLS listings. Disputes over listing terms, MLS timing, and extensions in private and pre-construction listings.
  • Buyer’s broker and cooperating broker claims. Unpaid cooperating compensation and buyer-broker agreement disputes.
  • Referral fees and commission splits. Disputes among agents, teams, and brokerages over referral and split agreements.
  • Auction and alternative sales. Commission rights when a listed property is sold by auction or another channel.

How We Build a Commission Case

Commission cases are usually won on the timeline: who knew what, and when. Sellers and their representatives rarely admit that a buyer was in the picture during the listing, so we build the timeline from the evidence.

  • Public records. Deeds, mortgages, and recording dates often show how long a deal was really in the works.
  • MLS and listing history. Listing entries, status changes, and timestamps can show whether a “relisting” came before or after the deal.
  • Contract and e-signature records. DocuSign trails and drafts establish when agreements were actually signed and became effective.
  • Communications. Texts, WhatsApp messages, and emails with the seller’s side, and the seller’s representatives’ own statements.
  • Social media. Public posts can show when a buyer first saw a property or moved in.
  • Third-party subpoenas. Closing agents, title companies, lenders, other brokerages, and platform providers often hold the records that settle the timeline.

Claims That May Be Available

Depending on the facts and the listing agreement, Florida law may support claims for:

  • Breach of the listing agreement, including the protection period and extension-through-closing provisions
  • Breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing
  • The prevention doctrine, when a party prevents the condition that would trigger the commission
  • Tortious interference with the listing agreement or the broker’s business relationship
  • Fraud, fraudulent concealment, and aiding and abetting fraud
  • Civil conspiracy and unjust enrichment
  • Prejudgment interest and, under most Florida Realtors forms, attorney’s fees and costs to the prevailing party

Florida courts and juries have shown a willingness to take these cases seriously, including significant damages verdicts where a commission was deliberately avoided. Every case depends on its own facts, and we give clients a straightforward assessment of both the strengths and the risks before any claim is filed.

What to Do If You Think Your Commission Was Taken

  • Preserve everything now. Save texts, WhatsApp chats, emails, voicemails, MLS alerts, showing records, and screenshots of social media posts. Turn off disappearing messages.
  • Pull the public record. Note the recording date of the deed and any mortgage.
  • Read your listing agreement. Note the term, the protection period, any additional terms, and the dispute-resolution clause.
  • Don’t sign releases or waivers or accept a reduced payment without advice.
  • Talk to counsel early. Evidence disappears, and pre-suit mediation and demand deadlines matter.

Why Brokers Choose Our Firm

  • Focused commercial litigation experience in high-value real estate and business disputes in Miami-Dade and throughout Florida.
  • Both sides of the table. We represent brokers and also defend sellers and developers, so we anticipate the defenses.
  • Investigation first. We develop the timeline from public records, MLS data, and third-party sources before we file.
  • Pre-suit to trial. Demand letters, required mediation, litigation, and trial.
  • Flexible fee arrangements, including contingency and hybrid structures where appropriate.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I get my commission if the listing expired before the house sold?

Often, yes. Most Florida listing agreements include a protection period that keeps the commission due if the property sells, within a set time after expiration, to a buyer who learned of it or was in contact during the listing. Many also extend the listing through closing if a contract is signed during the term. Whether you are protected depends on the exact wording of your agreement and on when the buyer first appeared, which is why the timeline matters so much.

What if the seller found the buyer, not me?

Under a Florida exclusive right of sale listing, the commission is typically owed no matter who finds the buyer, including the seller. A seller who deals directly with a buyer during the listing, or hides an inquiry until the listing ends, may still owe the full commission.

The property was “relisted” with another broker. Does that end my claim?

Not necessarily. Many listing agreements excuse the commission only if the property is truly relisted and then sold through the new broker. A listing created after the deal was already agreed, or a brokerage paid a token fee to put its name on a pre-arranged sale, may not meet that standard.

Can I sue the developer or buyer, not just the seller?

Sometimes. When a developer, a seller’s representative, a buyer, or another brokerage knowingly helps structure a sale to cut out the listing broker, Florida law may support claims such as tortious interference, fraud, aiding and abetting, or civil conspiracy against those parties as well.

Can I recover attorney’s fees?

Most Florida Realtors listing agreements award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs to the prevailing party. That can make it practical to pursue a claim, and it raises the stakes for the other side. It also means you should evaluate your claim carefully before filing.

How long do I have to bring a commission claim?

Florida generally allows five years to sue on a written contract, but other claims have shorter deadlines, and evidence such as text messages, social media posts, and MLS records can disappear quickly. Contact a lawyer as soon as you suspect a problem.

Do I have to go to mediation first?

Many listing agreements require mediation before a lawsuit can be filed. We handle that pre-suit process, including demand letters and mediation, and many cases resolve at that stage.

Do you represent sellers and developers too?

Yes. We also defend sellers, developers, and brokerages against commission claims. Knowing how these cases are defended helps us anticipate the defenses when we bring them.

What is procuring cause in a Florida commission dispute?

Where the written agreement does not settle the question, a broker generally must show that the broker brought the buyer and seller together and set in motion a continuous chain of events that ended in the sale, without abandoning the transaction.

Can an unlicensed person collect a real estate commission in Florida?

Generally, no. Under Chapter 475 of the Florida Statutes, a person or company without a Florida real estate license generally cannot lawfully receive a fee or commission for real estate brokerage services, and an agreement to pay one is generally unenforceable.

Can a broker put a lien on a property for an unpaid commission?

For a commercial real estate sale, Chapter 475 of the Florida Statutes may allow a broker owed a commission under a written brokerage agreement to claim a lien against the owner's net sale proceeds, not the property itself. Strict notice deadlines apply, usually before closing, with a limited exception when the broker did not know the owner had entered into a sale contract. Residential sales are not covered.

Does a commission dispute between brokers go to court or arbitration?

Some commission disputes between REALTORS who are principals at different firms must go to arbitration under the National Association of REALTORS Code of Ethics, Article 17, rather than Florida law. The rules contain exceptions, and clients generally must agree before a REALTOR association can arbitrate their dispute. Other commission disputes may be heard in court or resolved through arbitration if an agreement requires it.

Talk to a Miami Commission Dispute Attorney

If you believe you were cut out of a commission, or you are a seller or developer facing a commission claim, contact the Law Offices of Aaron Resnick for a confidential consultation. See also our commercial litigation practice.

Law Offices of Aaron Resnick

100 Biscayne Boulevard, Suite 1607, Miami, Florida 33132

(305) 672-7495 | Email Aaron Resnick

The information on this page is general and is not legal advice. Viewing this page or contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome; every case is different. The hiring of a lawyer is an important decision that should not be based solely upon advertisements.

Tell Aaron What Happened

Call 305-672-7495 Speak to Aaron

Contact Our Firm

Areas We Serve in Florida

Miami Gardens | Aventura | Golden Beach | Sunny Isles Beach | North Miami Beach | North Miami | Bal Harbour | Bay Harbor Islands | Indian Creek | Surfside | Biscayne Park | Miami Shores | El Portal | North Bay Village | Opa-locka | Miami Lakes | Hialeah | Hialeah Gardens | Medley | Doral | Miami Springs | Virginia Gardens | Sweetwater | Miami | Miami Beach | Key Biscayne | West Miami | Coral Gables | South Miami | Pinecrest | Palmetto Bay | Cutler Bay | Homestead | Florida City

Aaron Resnick Day, Miami Beach

Celebrating Aaron Resnick Day City of Miami Beach - Vibrant Art Deco Style Celebration Graphic with Palm Trees Fireworks and Neon Lights